What is Alternative Dispute Resolution?

The Oxford Dictionary defines alternative dispute resolution (ADR) as follows: “the use of methods such as mediation and arbitration to resolve a dispute instead of litigation.”  I suppose this helps paint the picture of ADR, but the logical follow-up questions are: What is arbitration?  -and- What is mediation?  For lawyers, these terms are self-evident, but for folks who don’t deal with the law every day, it only takes a casual reminder that these terms might as well be Latin.  So let’s start first with arbitration.

What is Arbitration?

Arbitration is defined as follows: “the hearing and determining of a dispute or the settling of differences between parties by a person or persons chosen or agreed to by them.”  It is important to note that arbitration looks a lot like traditional litigation.  There is typically a complaint, an answer, discovery, motions and a hearing that functions like a trial.  Arbitration, however, is typically privatized, while courts are governmental entities and judges are appointed or elected governmental officials.

Arbitration Vs. Litigation

This leads to one of the two biggest differences between arbitration and litigation in court: in traditional court litigation, court filings are public record and can be viewed by anyone.  In contrast, arbitration filings are private and are not disclosed publicly.

The second biggest difference between court litigation and arbitration is the trier of fact: in court litigation, you may have either a judge or a jury deciding the case.  In arbitration, the arbitrator takes the place of the judge or the jury.  And while judges or juries are appointed by the court, in arbitration, the parties can agree on who should be the arbitrator.  Notably, the parties have to pay the arbitrator, where judges and juries are paid by tax dollars. Other than these two significant differences related to public record and the trier of fact, arbitrations often look almost exactly like traditional court litigation.

What is Mediation?

Mediations, on the other hand, do not track a traditional litigation process.  Mediation is defined as “action in mediating between parties, as to effect an agreement or reconciliation.”  Mediation is a mutually agreed upon process where the parties hire a neutral party known as a mediator who listens to both sides of the dispute and then, without choosing a side, attempts to negotiate a mutually agreeable resolution between the parties to circumvent further litigation.  Courts may undertake mediation and, at times, engage in settlement conferences also intended to facilitate settlements between the parties.  But traditionally, like arbitration, mediation is privatized and the mediator is paid by the parties.  If mediation fails, or results in only partial resolution, the parties may continue down a more traditional litigation path.

Technology can Help ADR

Both arbitration and mediation were created as alternative paths to dispute resolution outside of traditional litigation in courts.  Whether existing arbitration and mediation have been successful in their current form is up for debate.  Currently, arbitration so closely resembles the time, cost, and process of traditional litigation that it’s difficult to discern where efficiencies actually exist.  Mediation, on the other hand, is an often useful tool but has no binding effect, giving parties the option to walk away if they are not getting the desired result. Still, the concept of alternative dispute resolution remains incredibly appealing to businesses and individuals alike. With some streamlining of the process and procedure, and the injection of technology, the true intention behind ADR can be realized.

Check out our other Blogs: Thoughts on the Immediate Future of Arbitration

More New Era Insights

Learn About Alternative Dispute Resolution

Hear stories from inside the court system and learn more about how ADR mediation and technology is offering a new path for dispute resolution.

50 Years of Title IX: Where Do We Go From Here? 

50 Years of Title IX: Where Do We Go From Here? 

If you’re a Title IX Coordinator, you know two things for sure:  You are the point-person for federal compliance.  And, that compliance is always changing. When interviewing for my Title IX Coordinator role I was told over and over again that the position came with...

The Gig Economy Needs a New Era of Arbitration

The Gig Economy Needs a New Era of Arbitration

A decade ago, significant litigation concerning the classification of gig workers began to surface. Recently there’s been renewed debate about the role of arbitration in the “gig” economy. Just this month, the Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court heard a case on...

The Title IX Coordinator Resource Guide

The Title IX Coordinator Resource Guide

Recently we sent out a survey within our Title IX Newsletter, asking Coordinators to share a little about your role. In an effort to help create a community, we thought it'd be helpful to pass along some of the shared resources, as well as some of the challenges of...

ODR is a Tool for Consumers to Resolve Disputes Quickly

ODR is a Tool for Consumers to Resolve Disputes Quickly

In this article we discuss how Online Dispute Resolution (ODR) is an easier and more efficient way to solve consumer disputes. 80% of the Global Population Uses Smartphones In 2011, Pew Research Center’s first survey of smartphone ownership determined that 35% of...

Get Started

Get Instant Access To Rapid Dispute Resolution

Create your free New Era ADR account and accelerate the resolution of your disputes.

Create My Account